(Long Island, N.Y.) There’s nothing like being dragged into a movie kicking and screaming, expecting it to be horrible beyond words, and actually leaving having been, at least to some small, tiny degree, entertained. Now, I’m not saying that I Am Number Four, a lame and blatant attempt to cash in on the success of Twilight, is actually a good movie, oh no…I’m just saying that, if you set your expectations low enough, you can see the good in just about anything.
So you can understand my reasons for expecting I Am Number Four to be the infected hangnail of motion pictures, let’s discuss author James Frey. You remember him, don’t you? He’s the guy that wrote the autobiographical “A Million Little Pieces,” a tome that chronicled his harrowing recovery from drug addiction. However, it came out that several incidents depicted in the book were…umm…”exaggerated,” to say the least. As a result, Mr. Frey endured a huge public backlash and even a televised tongue-lashing from no less than Oprah Winfrey herself, formerly one of his biggest supporters.
Anyway, Mr. Frey moved on, wrote some more books, and eventually started a publishing company whose purpose is to create highly-marketable, Twilight-like books that can then be turned into movies. Yes, seriously. Such a crass, shallow, and frankly lame business model aside, it also came out that Frey allegedly preys upon college students to pen his books, signing them into contracts that gave them no rights to their material, no real author credit, and a mere $250 advance. Again, allegedly (just covering myself here).
So, considering that the source material was created with only the most commercial of ideals involved, you can forgive me for expecting the movie to suck. But it actually doesn’t…well, not completely.
I Am Number Four is equal parts somewhat okay and unbelievably stupid. It’s the story of some kid named “John Smith” (that’s his alias…real name: “Number 4,” played by Alex Pettyfer), an alien hiding on Earth while on the run from his home planet with a group of evil invaders in tow. It seems that there’s special members of his race (who are named with numbers…I sure wouldn’t want to be “Number 2”) that get superpowers as they mature, and they’re all being hunted down and killed for some reason. As it serves the plot, John looks like a 25 year-old human who’s trying to pass himself off as a teenage boy.
As an aside – am I the only person sick of casting people who don’t look even remotely teenaged to play teens? I mean, damn.
Anyway, John has a bodyguard of sorts, Henri (Timothy Olyphant), who decides it’s best to “blend in” by enrolling John in high school. But how incognito can someone be when their hands glow in the middle of science class and weird, stupid-looking tattoos appear on their legs every time one of their brethren is killed?
So, as you were expecting, John encounters every teen movie stereotype in existence while at school: Sarah Hart (Dianna Agron), the misunderstood, artsy girl who’s “different” (as her defining trait, the screenwriters deemed that she must be obsessed with photography and thus, at all times, carry a camera with her); Mark James (Jake Abel), her mean, jealous ex-boyfriend (who, of course, she didn’t realize was mean and jealous until after she’d been dating him for ages); and Sam Goode (Callan McAuliffe), the socially awkward nerd who is repeatedly bullied by the mean, jealous ex-boyfriend of Sarah.
Things are complicated by the arrival of the evil alien invaders, who are perhaps the biggest problem with the movie. Remember that old Sylvester Stallone stinker Judge Dredd? There was this scene where Sly ends up in the “Cursed Earth,” which is basically a radioactive wasteland populated by in-bred, redneck mutants. There was one in particular who says something to the effect of “LEMME KILL IM, PAWWW!!” He’s bald, has rotten teeth, and just generally looks disgusting and even a bit retarded. THAT’S what the bud guys in I Am Number Four look like. Every one of them. If they were cool-looking Darth Vader-types or something it would have made for much better viewing, but there’s no way anyone could ever take the nuked cast of Deliverance seriously as a threat, even if they do have big ray-guns.
So, John, whose powers are now emerging (among them, his hands are now flashlights…seriously), falls in love with Sarah (except, on his planet, when you fall in love, it’s “FOREVER”…hahaha), and together the two have to deal with the invaders, Sarah’s ex-boyfriend and his jerky cop father, and the arrival of the mysterious “Number 6,” a girl from John’s planet who’s using her powers to fight instead of run away like sissy-boy John. Eventually, they team up to take on just about everybody.
I know I’ve been pretty critical of I Am Number Four thus far, but deservedly so; it’s corny, derivative, unoriginal, and just has a feeling of being mass-produced to coincide with any possible trend that could enable it to catch on to the Twilight crowd, with a sci-fi twist. However, the actors (especially Timothy Olyphant…what’s HE doing here?) all do solid jobs and can be occasionally likable, and that right there is more than I expected out of anyone associated with this movie. It also helps that there’s plenty of action and that it’s all very well done. Also, there’s a cute shape-shifting puppy!
But bear in mind, there’s nothing else even remotely good about I Am Number Four; there’s an abundance of horrible dialogue, no character development, and cheese galore (for example, several human characters suffer injuries that would kill dozens of real people, but appear just fine seconds later). But at least it caters to the base moviegoer’s instincts of excitement regarding watching pretty people and things that go “boom.”
So, I Am Number Four is actually pretty bad, but if you go into it with the right mindset – like expecting it to give you cancer – then you might just walk out somewhat satisfied like I did. Otherwise, unless you’re either a pre-teen girl or a sci-fi geek, avoid it.